Comments on: People’s War: People’s Defence http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence Tue, 31 Jan 2012 03:21:39 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Jatinder http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-66 Jatinder Tue, 23 Sep 2008 14:10:21 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-66 Thanks Arvinder for the valuable information..i have researched a lot on the events that led to the operation. At moments I found myself justifying the act of Indian military. But after reading you i think i need to search a lot more. specially your revelations about indian army planning operation since 1983 was really shocking. along with this i was reading about how sikhs in harayana were humiliated during asian games. i am very surprised how can a state do such things to its own citizens.... Thanks Arvinder for the valuable information..i have researched a lot on the events that led to the operation. At moments I found myself justifying the act of Indian military. But after reading you i think i need to search a lot more.
specially your revelations about indian army planning operation since 1983 was really shocking. along with this i was reading about how sikhs in harayana were humiliated during asian games. i am very surprised how can a state do such things to its own citizens….

]]> By: Maloy Krishna Dhar http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-65 Maloy Krishna Dhar Thu, 14 Aug 2008 10:20:20 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-65 Author speak: For Arwinder Singh. DEar Arwinder. Would you please read my books Open Secrets and Fulcrum of Evil and Black Thunder to understand my onterpretaion of the Punjab problem? After that you are welcome to get back to me at my mail address maloy39@gmail.com Best wishes. Author speak: For Arwinder Singh.
DEar Arwinder. Would you please read my books Open Secrets and Fulcrum of Evil and Black Thunder to understand my onterpretaion of the Punjab problem? After that you are welcome to get back to me at my mail address maloy39@gmail.com

Best wishes.

]]> By: Arwinder Singh http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-64 Arwinder Singh Thu, 14 Aug 2008 06:03:26 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-64 Hello Friends, Please dont make personal comments about Mr Dhar. This is a forum for discussion and bring ideas together and reform them. Every one has their limitations. Understanding and Visions has limitations. So does Mr Dhar. I think Mr Dhar was part of Government appratus has way of thinking from government perspective. I was a child when India's Army invaded Golden Temple. I have seen how Army acted during those days. I was in a bus from Amritsar to Taran Taran when Army stopped the bus and asked all Amritdhari's to come down. Amritdhari's were favourite hunt of Army in those days. Lets ask Mr Dhar to reflect about greatest devil that existed in India. Mr Dhar, Do you have any single Case registered against Bhindranwale in whole of India? If you have please scan it and put it on your website as well. People should know in what crime he was wanted. Please also scan the warrant that were issued by court to arrest him that police couldnt execute so Army has to go in. Oh one more thing Just prior to invasion of Golden Temple Deputy Commssioner of Amritsar was Gurdev Singh. Did he asked Army to come and help him? You are quite famous in revealing hidden truths. Why dont you tell readers who started terrorism in punjab? Does Mr SK Sinha lies when he says Indian Army was preparing to launch Operation Bllue Star since early 1983? MR SK Sinha is a retired Lt General of Indian Army. Bhindranwale was no where close to Golden Temple at that time? Who smuggled Arms into Golden Temple? Was Bhindranwale controlling entire BSF, Punjab Police, Indian Army as well? Do you want to know how this single event has changed relationship of Sikhs with India? In 1961 War with Pakistan entire western border saw Sikh officers. Now Sikhs are quitely skipping to join Indian Armed Forces and they are begging Prince Charles to raise Sikh Regiments? Do you see where history is leading us to ?????? We dont know where history will lead us to but please Stop lieing. That might come handy later on. Hello Friends,

Please dont make personal comments about Mr Dhar. This is a forum for discussion and bring ideas together and reform them. Every one has their limitations. Understanding and Visions has limitations. So does Mr Dhar. I think Mr Dhar was part of Government appratus has way of thinking from government perspective.

I was a child when India’s Army invaded Golden Temple. I have seen how Army acted during those days. I was in a bus from Amritsar to Taran Taran when Army stopped the bus and asked all Amritdhari’s to come down. Amritdhari’s were favourite hunt of Army in those days.

Lets ask Mr Dhar to reflect about greatest devil that existed in India. Mr Dhar, Do you have any single Case registered against Bhindranwale in whole of India? If you have please scan it and put it on your website as well. People should know in what crime he was wanted. Please also scan the warrant that were issued by court to arrest him that police couldnt execute so Army has to go in.

Oh one more thing Just prior to invasion of Golden Temple Deputy Commssioner of Amritsar was Gurdev Singh. Did he asked Army to come and help him?

You are quite famous in revealing hidden truths. Why dont you tell readers who started terrorism in punjab? Does Mr SK Sinha lies when he says Indian Army was preparing to launch Operation Bllue Star since early 1983? MR SK Sinha is a retired Lt General of Indian Army. Bhindranwale was no where close to Golden Temple at that time?

Who smuggled Arms into Golden Temple? Was Bhindranwale controlling entire BSF, Punjab Police, Indian Army as well?

Do you want to know how this single event has changed relationship of Sikhs with India? In 1961 War with Pakistan entire western border saw Sikh officers. Now Sikhs are quitely skipping to join Indian Armed Forces and they are begging Prince Charles to raise Sikh Regiments? Do you see where history is leading us to ??????

We dont know where history will lead us to but please Stop lieing. That might come handy later on.

]]> By: Malagiri Kamar http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-63 Malagiri Kamar Sat, 05 Jul 2008 03:37:02 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-63 We are warriors of destiny. Dhar has a romantic approach to Naxalism. Things have changed Old Boy. We are determined to fight and gain freedom. We are warriors of destiny. Dhar has a romantic approach to Naxalism. Things have changed Old Boy. We are determined to fight and gain freedom.

]]> By: Venkata Reddy http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-62 Venkata Reddy Sat, 05 Jul 2008 03:35:20 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-62 Dhar behaves as an agent of the government. Marxist-Leninist-Maoist revolution is the only weapon to free India from the clutches of Congress+Caste Baron parties. Our war would continue Dhar behaves as an agent of the government. Marxist-Leninist-Maoist revolution is the only weapon to free India from the clutches of Congress+Caste Baron parties. Our war would continue

]]> By: Susanne Tracy http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-61 Susanne Tracy Mon, 16 Jun 2008 03:37:02 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-61  I read the article with interest. A student in Cornell University studying intelligence related subject I wonder if Mr. Dhar would like to enlighten us on the concept of Mass Control. We have some course materials on that but very sketchy ground level experiences are shared with us. It is fascinating subject and is most applicable in areas affected by insurgency and terrorism   I read the article with interest. A student in Cornell University studying intelligence related subject I wonder if Mr. Dhar would like to enlighten us on the concept of Mass Control. We have some course materials on that but very sketchy ground level experiences are shared with us. It is fascinating subject and is most applicable in areas affected by insurgency and terrorism 

]]> By: Samir Samanta http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-60 Samir Samanta Sat, 07 Jun 2008 12:17:10 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-60 I am unable to understand the political and operationsl philosophy enuncitd by Dhar. Does he want civil war? Or would like to enlighten us more on the theory and practice of mass control? I am unable to understand the political and operationsl philosophy enuncitd by Dhar. Does he want civil war? Or would like to enlighten us more on the theory and practice of mass control?

]]> By: Oman Tharur http://maloykrishnadhar.com/peoples-war-peoples-defence#comment-59 Oman Tharur Sat, 31 May 2008 11:29:24 +0000 http://maloykrishnadhar.com/?p=55#comment-59 A fine analysis of strategy to fight terrorism. The author has insight. A fine analysis of strategy to fight terrorism. The author has insight.

]]>