Maloy Krishna Dhar

The Warriors of Allah

Posted on | April 15, 2009 | 94 Comments

Recent pronouncements by several US authorities, comments by US/UK security and intelligence experts and even some transparent Pakistani politicians expressed the likelihood of Taliban (al Qaeda backed) forces sweeping Pakistan and taking over political reins of the country. The desperate attitude of top Pakistani politicians indicate that in the face of Taliban, Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (al Qaeda ally), Laskar-e-Taiba, Jais-e-Mohammad (allied to Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan) and some al Qaeda raiders Pakistan’s very existence is in jeopardy. These forces have occupied the entire Waziristan in NWFP, established control on Peshawar, Quetta, Bannu, Mohmand etc administrative centres and have carried out tantalizing attacks in Lahore, Islamabad, Chakwal, Multan, besides several attacks in Karachi.

David Kilcullen, a former adviser to top US military commander General David Petraeus and a top counterinsurgency expert feels that Pakistan could collapse within six months. The same concern has been expressed by NATO experts. In a report released in February 2009 by a task force of the Atlantic Council that was led by former Senator Chuck Hagel of Nebraska and Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts said: “We are running out of time to help Pakistan change its present course toward increasing economic and political instability, and even ultimate failure.”

President Obama and his European allies are ready with huge financial and military assistance to induce Pakistan to combat the Taliban, al Qaeda. President Zardari and Chief General Pervez Kiyani may be willing to go for the Taliban. But to the Pakistan Army core, the ISI, parts of the bureaucrats and the Mullah community dominated political and civil leaders consider India as the Foremost Enemy and are not willing to engage the main body of the Army to combat the Taliban, al Qaeda and myriads of jihadi tanjeems created by the State of Pakistan and the ISI.

Pakistan, as India asserts, is in a denial mode. The Chief Capital Police (CCPO) of Lahore Pervaiz Rathore said on 10th April that the police had gathered concrete evidence of Indian involvement in the Lahore attack on Sir Lanka cricket team. The political masters appear to have buried their heads like ostrich. They also talk in ambivalent voices and refuse to recognize, despite major attacks on Lahore PTS and Islamabad.
While refusing to disclose the proof, Rathore said the police would make all evidences public at the appropriate time. He said the police and intelligence agencies had jointly interrogated terrorists arrested during the attack on the school. He said they had confessed to their links with India. Such self-delusionary statements indicate that Pakistan is yet to accept the stark naked truth that the Taliban and other Warriors of Allah are on the verge of overrunning Pakistan. They still try to compel Pakistanis to live under the so-called shadow of the Indian dodo.


The truth was, however, revealed by another grassroots police officer. NWFP police Chief Malik Navid told the Pakistan National Assembly’s standing committee that the extremist organisations were spreading rapidly through the country and were no longer confined to the mountains of NWFP or Waziristan. He said the terrorists’ aims included destabilisation of current regimes in the Middle East – a long-term objective of al-Qaida chief Osama bin Laden and establishing Taliban rule over entire Pakistan. The Talibanis are capable of swarming Islamabad as their encampments are within 100 kilometres of the capital city.

Pointing to the unchecked progress of jihadi groups, Navid said Taliban were moving towards major cities like Lahore and Karachi. “Their people are present in every city and town. In some places they are active, in others they are dormant. Taliban’s philosophy is to create pockets everywhere,” he said, adding that jihadi groups were moving through southern Punjab and eventually aimed to reach the financial hub of Karachi. (Quoted in Daily Times of Pakistan 11.04.09)

Navid, according to reports from Pakistan, said that the al-Qaida-Taliban combo hoped to use parts of the Middle East as launching pads for attacks against the West and pointed out that the groups had developed some expertise in making bio-chemical weapons. He warned that the Pakistan government needed to urgently focus on containing militancy as it spread from its bases. It is needless to point out that despite Pakistani assurance of foolproof security of its nuclear arsenal it is known to IAEA experts and the CIA that scientists close A. Q. Khan are in touch with the al Qaeda supremo.

The frank assessment of the police official serves to confirm concerns about whether Pakistan and its military complex in particular is prepared to unambiguously acknowledge the threat posed by jihadists given the army and ISI see Taliban as allies and an auxiliary force in ensuring a “friendly” dispensation in Afghanistan and feeding the jihad in Jammu and Kashmir. The Pakistan army’s sporadic efforts to roll back jihadis have lacked conviction and have predictably shown poor results. Some western experts say that the ISI and Pakistan and Afghanistan Taliban are in cahoots. The Newsweek commented in a recent issue: “According to a Pakistani source who follows the issue, high-level American officials have shared with their counterparts in Islamabad some intelligence indicating that renegade ISI elements helped Mehsud’s group train for the December 2007 assassination of Pakistan’s former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, whose widower, Asif Ali Zardari, is now the country’s president.”

Pakistan’s Establishment’s psyche is confined in a witch’s mirror. It refuses to see the truth and act to break out of the glass cage. The patronage extended to Deobandi and Wahhabi groups by Pakistan’s army and ISI since 1980 for operations in Afghanistan and anti-India operations had given birth to HUJI, Harkat-ul Ansar and Hizb-ul-Mujahideen etc tanzeems. They were seen to be more brutal and ready to carry out the directions of their handlers than aboriginal Kashmiri outfits. These outfits created by ISI and Deobandi-Wahhabi Maulanas were tied in with the rise of Taliban, who came from the same ideological base. Ironically, having facilitated escape of Taliban leaders from Afghanistan after 9/11, Pakistan now faces the same threat at home.

Navid’s testimony also points to the virtual merger of al-Qaida with Taliban, with the latter being both part of the core and the major striking arm. The al-Qaida core of leaders like bin Laden and the Eqyptian Ayman Al Zawahiri has shrunk but its “vision” can be seen in the overall jihadi plan to topple the Pakistani state. Indian intelligence assessments see anti-India groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba being very much a part of this conglomerate.

In the context of these observations by Mr. Navid and Daily Times we need examining the groundswell of the Taliban groups in Pakistan. I had written on August 8, 2008 in this portal about than prevailing position of the Taliban groups:

Major Taliban Groups:
1.Taliban Classical- Mullah Omar
2.Maulavi Jalaluddin Haqqani Group
3.Tehrik-e-Teluba; Mullah Safi; Orakzai Agency
4.Tehrik-e-Teluba: Mullah Jalali
5.Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan; Baitullah Mehsud
6.Splinter Taliban Groups in Swat, Waziri and NWFP areas:
Md. Mokhtar Mujahid; Mufti Latifullah Hakim;
Md. Yusof; All loosely connected to Mehsud and Khalili Groups.
7.Tehrik-e-Nifaz-Shariat Mohammadi; Maulana Fazlullah
8.Maulvi Nazir & Tehir Yuldashev groups
9.Tora-Bora Taliban created by son late Maulavi Khalis
10.Tehrik-e-Taliban; Omar Khalid Group
11.Lashkar-e-Taiba; Jais-e-Mohammad; Lashkar-e-Jhangvi
Lashkar-e-Mohammadia wax and wane with major Taliban groups.

Recent studies indicate some major changes:

(A Who’s Who of the Insurgency in Pakistan’s North-West Frontier Province: Part Two – FATA excluding North and South Waziristan
Publication: Terrorism Monitor Volume: 7 Issue: 4
March 3, 2009 10:46 AM Age: 42 days
Category: Terrorism, South Asia, Home Page, Terrorism Monitor, Global Terrorism Analysis
By: Rahimullah Yusufzai
)

The Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) is the largest organization of Pakistani militants operating in the country’s North-West Frontier Province (NWFP), which includes the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA). Launched in a secret meeting on December 13, 2007, it is active in most of the 24 districts, seven tribal agencies and six frontier regions in the province. The militants’ strongholds are in South Waziristan, North Waziristan, Orakzai, Kurram, Khyber, Mohmand, Bajaur, and Darra Adamkhel tribal regions and in the settled districts of Swat, Upper Dir, Lower Dir, Bannu, Lakki Marwat, Tank, Peshawar, Dera Ismail Khan, Mardan, Charsadda, and Kohat, Miranshah, Haripur and Abottabad.

The following is a profile of important Pakistani Taliban commanders active in areas of the NWFP and FATA and South Waziristan and North Waziristan.

Bajaur Agency

In Bajaur Agency, where Pakistan’s armed forces launched an intensive military campaign against militants on August 6, 2008, the mainstream TTP is led by Maulana Faqir Mohammad, a former leader of the banned Islamic group Tanzim Nifaz Shariat-i-Mohammadi (TNSM). The group’s founder, Maulana Sufi Mohammad, is presently playing an active role in peacefully resolving the two-year-old conflict in Swat district. In 1994, the black-turbaned followers of Maulana Sufi Mohammad (commanded by Maulana Faqir Mohammad) turned to violence in support of their demand for enforcement of Shari’a (Islamic law) in Bajaur and the rest of the Malakand area in Swat.

Maulana Faqir Mohammad, leader of the mainstream TTP, Jamestown.org

Maulana Faqir Mohammad, leader of the mainstream TTP, Jamestown.org

Maulana Faqir Mohammad is a resident of Sewai village in Bajaur’s Mamond area, a stronghold for the Pakistani Taliban. He belongs to a family of clerics who fought in Afghanistan during the Afghan jihad against the Soviet occupation and later as allies of the Taliban. The TTP in Bajaur is reported to have several thousand fighters and supporters. They put up stiff resistance against the Pakistani security forces but the military campaign has diminished their strength and disrupted their command structure and supply routes to other tribal regions, as well as Afghanistan’s Kunar and Nuristan provinces. The TTP managed to establish a Shari’a court in Sewai village with six branches in different parts of Bajaur. The courts were part of the parallel administration that the TTP set up before the military moved in and took tough action against the group.

Another militant group operating in Bajaur is the Jaish-e-Islami, which parted ways with the TTP in 2008 but now appears to have mended fences with the TTP in a desperate bid to resist the Pakistan Army’s operation. Led by Waliur Rahman a.k.a. Raihan, the group consists of militants hailing from the Bajaur village of Damadola. Attacked with laser-guided missiles three times by CIA-operated Predator drones in 2007 and 2008, Damadola enjoys special status with the Islamist movement in Bajaur. Another important figure in the group, which used to have several hundred fighters before the military operation in August 2008, is Maulana Ismail. There were reports that Waliur Rahman had developed some differences with Maulana Faqir Mohammad, but these were apparently not serious in nature and are reported to have been resolved.

Prior to the army’s campaign in Bajaur, the Karwan-e-Niamatullah was considered one of the most powerful groups in Bajaur. Led by Haji Niamatullah of the Salarzai area, the group stuck with the TTP despite having some differences with its policies. At its height, the group had several thousand fighters. It suffered losses when tribesmen from the Salarzai area formed a tribal lashkar (an armed force usually raised with a specific objective), with support from the government and under the leadership of their tribal chiefs. The lashkar started chasing out the militants, who retaliated with suicide bombings, one of which killed scores of their armed rivals, including some tribal elders. The Karwan-i-Niamatullah established its own Shari’a court in Pashat, the main town of the Salarzai area, but the group has since been uprooted from there.

Dr. Ismail (a quack) is another powerful commander in Bajaur. He was affiliated earlier with Pakistan’s biggest religious-political party, the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) of Maulana Fazlur Rahman, who recently declared that the government has no writ in any part of the NWFP (Daily Times, February 20). Dr. Ismail once employed the services of a few hundred fighters until the military struck in Bajaur and pushed his group out of their strongholds. Two young sons of Dr. Ismail were killed in Afghanistan. The TTP considers him and his supporters as part of the organization. However, Dr. Ismail is against the TTP’s policy of fighting against Pakistan’s armed forces. Instead, he wants the Pakistani Taliban and other militants to concentrate on fighting the U.S.-led coalition forces in neighboring Afghanistan. He has steady links with several Army and ISI operatives.

Maulana Abdullah is another known commander of the militants in Bajaur. He is affiliated with the TTP and has operated mostly in the Charmang and Utmankhel areas of Bajaur. At one time he had a few hundred fighters at his command. Also operating until recently in the Charmang area was an Afghan Taliban commander named Saeedur Rahman. He seems to have become less active after being warned by the Afghan Taliban to decide whether he wants to fight in Afghanistan or Pakistan.

Mohmand Agency

Two militant groups are known to have operated in Mohmand Agency. One of the groups was evicted after a clash with the TTP cadres in the area. Its commander, Shah Sahib a.k.a. Commander Khalid, was active in Mohmand Agency for two years until July 2008, when TTP fighters led by Omar Khalid a.k.a. Abdul Wali overran his base and killed him and several of his men. Shah Sahib, a known Salafi, did not want to fight the Pakistani state or its armed forces. From his camp near the Pakistani-Afghan border, Shah Sahib sent his followers to fight in Afghanistan. He had several hundred fighters in his group, which was commonly known in the area as the Jamait Ahle Hadith, Pakistan.

A larger group of militants was led by Omar Khalid was affiliated to Baitullah Mehsud’s TTP. It emerged from obscurity in July 2007, when its fighters captured the shrine of Haji Sahib Turangzai (1858-1937), a social reformer, anti-British freedom-fighter, and religious scholar, in the Lakarro area of Mohmand Agency. Omar Khalid’s group renamed the mosque adjacent to the shrine “Lal Masjid” after the radical mosque in Islamabad that was the site of a bloody siege by security forces in July 2007. The group pledged to avenge the killing of Lal Masjid’s religious students at the hands of the Pakistan Army and President General Pervez Musharraf. The group extended its control over most of the Mohmand Agency when it publicly slaughtered notorious criminal Yousaf Khan and seven members of the gang and evicted the rival Ahle Hadith militants group of Commander Shah Khalid. Some of his fighters were also deputed to Indian Kashmir as Khalid was earlier involved in Kashmir jihad. This group of Omar Khalid is strong followers of orthodox Salafi tenets preached by Osama bin Laden.

Initially, the shrine of Haji Sahib Turangzai was turned into a base for the militants and a Shari’a court with Afghan scholar Sayyad as the judge was set up. The group had several hundred fighters but its strength was reduced following the military operation in Mohmand Agency in late 2008 and early 2009. Tribal elders from Mohmand recently expressed their support for continuing military operations in the area by the Mohmand Rifles of the paramilitary Frontier Corps.

Darra Adamkhel

Darra is the unofficial armament factory in Pakistan. There are three groups of Pakistani Taliban operating in Darra Adamkhel, a semi-tribal area known officially as the Frontier Region of Kohat. It has a strategic location due to its position on the main road linking Peshawar to the southern NWFP and beyond via the Kohat Tunnel, which was built by Japanese engineers and opened in 2003. The groups active in Darra Adamkhel are the Tehrik-e-Islami, Islami Taliban, and al-Hezb.

The Tehrik-e-Islami and the Islami Taliban became active in the area in mid-2007. The former was founded by a local Afridi tribesman named Muneer Khan, while the Islami Taliban was founded by Momin Afridi. The groups later merged and became part of the TTP. Both leaders were killed in a military operation in the area in 2008. Leadership then passed to Commander Mohammad Tariq, a tribesman hailing from the Bazidkhel Afridi tribe. Another important commander is Mufti Ilyas, a resident of the Sheraki area of Darra Adamkhel. Mufti Ilyas is now deputy to Commander Tariq and acts as a sort of ideologue for the group.

Another known commander is Hamza Afridi, who the group’s spokesman calls simply Mohammad. Several months ago the group kidnapped a Polish engineer, Petr Stanczak, from the Attock district in Punjab and killed him in February 2009 after Pakistan government refused to accept a demand for the release of its members. The group has several hundred fighters under its command. Following the military operation, the militants lost control of the Kohat Tunnel and the Darra bazaar, a gun-manufacturing center for over a century. The leadership has shifted to the adjacent Orakzai Agency, but the group’s fighters are still able to occasionally attack security forces in the area.

An obscure group calling itself al-Hezb made its appearance in Darra Adamkhel in late 2008 by distributing pamphlets and leaflets and pasting them in shops. Al-Hezb declared its opposition to the other militant groups and offered an alternative platform. However, al-Hezb never held any public meetings and its leaders are still unknown. In fact, it has even stopped distributing leaflets. Both militants and tribesmen in Darra Adamkhel felt it was part of a trick by the government to confuse the Taliban groups and create differences in their ranks.

Kurram Agency

The TTP, through its regional commander Hakimullah Mahsud, has set up bases in the Lower Kurram valley, which is inhabited by Sunnis, unlike the Upper Kurram valley where the Shi’a are in the majority. Recently, the U.S. carried out its first Predator missile strike in Kurram against an alleged hideout of Afghan Taliban in an Afghan refugee camp. The attack killed at least 26 people, including several militants (Daily Times, February 17).

stratfor.com

stratfor.com

Taliban & al Qaeda controlled areas in Pakistan

Orakzai Agency

The TTP has sanctuaries in the Orakzai Agency, a tribal territory with a Sunni majority and Shia minority. Orakzai is the only tribal region in Pakistan that does not border Afghanistan. Hakimullah Mahsud, a young tribesman from South Waziristan and a deputy to TTP head Baitullah Mehsud, operates out of Oarkzai Agency and is also commander of the militants in the Kurram and Khyber tribal regions. A young man in his late 20s, Hakimullah Mahsud invited the media to his hideout in Orakzai Agency in November 2008 to give his first news conference. This interaction enabled him to emerge from the shadows of Baitullah Mehsud and become known as a commander in his own right.

Khyber Agency

Kamran Mustafa Hijrat a.k.a. Mohammad Yahya Hijrat was, until a few months ago, the top Taliban commander in the Khyber Agency, which is named after the famous Khyber Pass that serves as a gateway between Central and South Asia and has been the route taken by invaders, conquerors, and traders for centuries. Hijrat was arrested in Peshawar’s Hayatabad town in late 2008 and is now in the custody of Pakistan’s security services.

Hijrat was a deputy to Hakimullah Mahsud and was reportedly responsible for attacks on trucks carrying supplies for NATO forces in Afghanistan. His men also burnt more than 300 vehicles destined for Afghanistan at a terminal for NATO trucks on Peshawar’s Ring Road. Hijrat is an Afghan by birth and was a small-time Afghan Taliban commander before making it big as a member of the Pakistani TTP. His deputy, Rahmanullah, also an Afghan national, has taken over as acting commander of TTP for Khyber Agency.
 
Several non-Taliban Islamist militant groups are active in Khyber Agency, mostly in the Bara area. These include Mangal Bagh’s Lashkar-i-Islam, the late Haji Namdar’s Amr Bil Maruf wa Nahi Anil Munkar (Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice), and Ustad Mahbubul Haq’s Ansar-ul-Islam.

Bailullah Mehsud, TTP leader, threatening occupation of entire Pakistan. http://bangaluunderattack.blogspot.com/

Bailullah Mehsud, TTP leader, threatening occupation of entire Pakistan. http://bangaluunderattack.blogspot.com/

{end of jamestown.org article}

Waziristan Groups

Two major Pakistani Taliban groups based in Waziristan are the North Waziristan faction led by Hafiz Gul Bahadar. It has strength of about 2000 fighters. The South Waziristan faction, led by Mullah Nazir led another 2000 odd Talibanis. The North and South group divided into divergent Khels had agreed in late 2008 to put an end to a local feud and their differences with Baitullah Mehsud, the overall leader of the Pakistani Taliban. The three groups have joined forces to prevent outside enemies from dividing the Taliban.

The three leaders met at an undisclosed location in the Waziristan region. The Taliban warlords agreed to form a 13 member shura, or council. Leadership of the shura would rotate and Baitullah, Nazir, and Bahadar would sit on the council. It is unclear if Nazir and Bahadar will join Baitullah’s Tehrik-e-Taliban, or the Movement of the Taliban in Pakistan. There are reports of strong ISI support to the Waziri groups. Baitullah’s group, which operates in all of the tribal areas and throughout the Northwest Frontier Province, has defeated the Pakistani military in multiple battles, forcing the government to cut peace agreements. The move to unite the Waziristan factions comes as the Taliban achieved its greatest victory yet by humiliating government forces in Swat and forcing the state to cede a vast region in the Northwest Frontier Province. Mullah Fazlullah, the second in command of the Tehrik-e-Taliban, has led the fighting in Swat.

South Waziri TTP leader Mullah Nazir, Bill Roggio; THe Long War Journal

South Waziri TTP leader Mullah Nazir, Bill Roggio; THe Long War Journal

Taliban forces in Pakistan are now spread over the entire Federally Administered Territory (FATA), Waziristan areas of NWFP, other major pockets of the province and even several blocks in Quetta region of Balochistan. The reports about Taliban and Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) collaboration are yet to be convincingly established. However, it is correct that several Taliban groups of Mullah Omar (Afghanistan) have set up camps in areas of Balochistan.

Besides territorial spread the Pak Taliban and al Qaeda forces are now located in major cities and towns like Islamabad, Rawalpindi, Lahore, Karachi, Peshawar, and Quetta and in several districts in Jhang Maghiana area of Punjab. Besides Pathan, frontier tribals, Afghani Pustuns several groups of Seraiki, Punjabi, Hindco and Pustu, Sindhi and Balochi speaking Pakistanis are now spearheading the jihadi groups. Lashkar-e-Jhangvi, originally formed in Jhang area of Punjab as an anti-Shia armed force (Sipaha Sahaba) is now directly aligned with the al Qaeda. L-e-J was suspected in the Lahore attack case on the Sri Lanka cricket team. Some of the attackers spoke in Seraiki language. It may be mentioned that the Seraiki speaking people of Pakistan and India (Hindu) have a strong organisatinsl base and they resent Punjabi hegemony.

According to SABRINA TAVERNISE, RICHARD A. OPPEL Jr. and ERIC SCHMITT (International Herald Tribune, April 13, 2009): “Tell-tale signs of creeping militancy abound in a belt of towns and villages near here that a reporter visited last week. Militants have gained strength considerably in the district of Dera Ghazi Khan, which is a gateway both to Taliban-controlled areas and the heart of Punjab, police and local residents say. Many were terrified.

Some villages, just north of here, are so deeply infiltrated by militants that they are already considered no-go zones by their neighbors.

In at least five towns in southern and western Punjab, including the midsize hub of Multan, barber shops, music stores and Internet cafes offensive to the militants’ strict interpretation of Islam have received threats. Traditional ceremonies that include drumming and dancing have been halted in some areas. Hard-line ideologues have addressed large crowds to push their idea of Islamic revolution. Sectarian attacks, dormant here since the 1990s, have erupted once again.” The total picture drawn by the scribes indicate that even rural areas of Punjab have been infiltrated by al Qaeda, Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan and local tanzeems.

Another report supports the view that Lashkar-e-Taiba is training nearly 20,000 lashkars every year and bulk of the trained boys is deputed to Pakistani tribal areas and Afghanistan, besides Indian Kashmir. The training centres are very much located in Pakistani Punjab.

More alarming are the reports of the TTP occupying Buner district just about 100 km from Islamabad. Reports say that having forcibly taken over Buner district adjoining Swat Valley, Taliban militants have begun using mosques in the area as “recruitment centres” to attract youths to join their ranks. Almost all mosques in villages in Buner district are being used by the Taliban to recruit local residents for their cause of enforcing Sharia or Islamic law in the Malakand division, which includes Swat and the rest of the country, media reports said on Monday.

The entry of Taliban into Buner, which is just about 100 km from the federal capital, has raised alarm throughout Pakistan as to the intentions of the Taliban. Armed bands of Taliban poured into Buner from neighbouring Swat and took control of the district after overcoming resistance from local tribesmen and officials. The militants on Sunday (April 12) placed villages in Chamla sub-district of Buner under their protection and faced no resistance from law enforcement agencies. Despite assurances to a tribal jirga last week that they would leave Buner, the militants have instead strengthened their hold on the district.

Maulana Khalil, a Taliban leader from Swat, addressed a congregation in a mosque in Malakpur village where he was welcomed by clerics and a large number of local residents. He urged youths to come forward and shoulder the responsibility for enforcing Sharia in their areas. Khalil said the movement for enforcing Sharia in Malakand division had started 20 years ago but the peaceful campaign could not achieve results. Thus it had to be turned into an armed movement to enforce Sharia. He also said the Tehrik-e-Taliban had to spread its message in the rest of Pakistan and youths must come forward to shoulder the responsibility in their respective areas. Other Taliban commanders asked youths across Buner to join their group to take control of their own localities. They said the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan has roots within and outside the country.

Besides the Pakistani nationals the al Qaeda and TTP ranks are also manned by Arabs, Chechens, Uzbeks, Uyghurs (China), Tajiks and even some professional fighters from Yemen, UAE, the Philippines and Bangladesh. The panorama has taken a wide spectrum Islamist presence on both sides of the Durand Line and both Kabul and Islamabad governments have failed to contain the march of the Warriors of Allah. While Osama bin Laden aspires to take over the heartland of the Middle East and direct Jihad against the infidel West, the TTP and allied forces are determined to take over entire Pakistan and convert it to a pure land of Islam-as earlier witnessed in Mullah Omar’s Afghanistan. Though the Muslim elites are aware that success of the Taliban would push the Muslim masses back in history by about 1300 years, they are not chipping in their best to contain the Warriors of Allah.

After several disastrous military expeditions and regular US UAV shelling Pakistan failed to tame the al Qaeda and several factions of the TTP. It realized that TTP etc were front formations of al Qaeda and Pakistan was not able to contain the surge of the Warrior of the Allah. Pakistan’s civil government is ineffective and several segments of the Army are not in favour of getting locked up in the killing fields of Swat and Waziristan. It is known that sections in the ISI are informers of Baitullah Mehsud. Maulana Sufi Muhammad, chief of banned outfit Tehreek-e-Nifaz-e-Shariah-e-Muhammadi (TNSM), and the NWFP government headed by Chief Minister Amir Haider Khan Hoti signed an agreement on February 15, 2009 which reached understanding to extend Nizam-e-Adl Regulation (Shariat Rule) in the entire areas controlled by the TTP and allied forces. Maulana Fazlullah, Baitullah Mehsud, Maulana Sufi Mohammad agreed to maintain peace and surrender weapons once President Asif Ali Zardari approved the Nizam-e-Adl Regulation. Fazlullah said this during a meeting with Swat peace Jirga head Inamur Rehman. Talking to reporters after the meeting Rehman said Fazlullah had told him that the Taliban in Swat would not lay down their arms until the president signed the regulation.

While these negotiations are in progress to push back certain parts of Pakistan to the dark ages (recall a recently published BBC video of a tribal woman lashed by the Taliban in Swat area). The dark memories of Taliban rule are afresh in mind. With Baitullah Mehsud threatening to take over entire Pakistan and the main soul of Pakistan-the Army and ISI dithering to take firm action it is a matter of time before these Warriors of the Allah take charge of the reins of Pakistan.

Finally President Zardari managed to present the Nizam-e-Adil regulations in the National Assembly on April 13, and after approval of the MNAs (minus MQM). Constitutionally it was not necessary to present the Bill in the NA. Zardari did so to send a message to USA and other donor countries that he signed the Shariat Rule Bill under pressure of the majority of the MNAs of Pakistani parliament. The charade was not lost on the USA and allies. According to sources in Washington the USA is seriously examining how to digest the bitter pill of Shariat rule in parts of Pakistan where the US tax payers were being asked to invest out of their pockets.
The US, Russia and other Donor countries are aware that by succumbing to TTP demand Pakistan has initiated the process of Talibanisation of entire Pakistan. In fact, Afghanistan, CAR countries, Iran, Pakistan, India and Bangladesh are threatened by al Qaeda and Taliban and their allied tanzeems. Such a strategic development is dangerous for the Middle East, Western countries, CAR countries and India particularly.
Before considering these geostrategic dangers let us examine the grassroots grouping of the al Qaeda and Taliban forces. We must have clear understanding of the Afghan Taliban, which is now a part & parcel of al Qaeda and TTP.

Antonio Giustozzi, a research fellow at the London School of Economics had studied the evolution of the Taliban since 9/11. Giustozzi feels that Taliban is not a single ethnic group.
He describes it as a religious network which turned into a political movement. And then they started expanding — co-opting other religious networks, and then gradually going beyond those religious networks to start forming alliances with local communities or local power players.

Taliban lacks a strong organizational structure and is essentially still a network based on personal relations between the leadership and people at the local level owing allegiance to local commanders, who are mostly motivated by flourishing opium. Heroin trade and cash support.

According to Giustozzi Mullah Omar is not an authoritative leader. He is more like a broker among different members of the leadership who may have differences over issues of how to fight the war or whether to negotiate or not. So in a sense, it is modeled from their experience as clerics.

In his recently published book, “Koran, Kalashnikov And Laptop: The Neo Taliban Insurgency In Afghanistan,” Giustozzi describes how the Taliban leadership has recently embraced new strategies and technologies, including computers and suicide bombings. Giustozzi’s book also describes how the Taliban has reorganized and adapted to changing political conditions in Afghanistan since 2002.

“Of course, the top leaders are people who have been with the Taliban for a long, long time. So in that sense, the very top leaders are still the same. What is new is that they are trying to incorporate new constituencies and, therefore, represent different tribes and communities. So as their constituencies change, they also adapt to those constituencies,” Giustozzi says. He says the original Taliban were largely Ghilzai, while in 2003 and 2004, the majority of the leadership were actually Durannis. Other tribes have also joined the bandwagon of Mullah Omar.

According to Giustozzi the modern Taliban are essentially a guerrilla movement, whereas in the 1990s — even in the early days of 1994 or 1995 — they fought like regular army. In that sense, the main difference is the way they operate.

Working for the United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan, Christine Fair last year studied the phenomenon of suicide bombings across Afghanistan. Her work led to important conclusions not only about suicide bombers, but also about the emergence of this new generation of Taliban fighters. Her opinion is that: “The important big picture is Afghans like to tell you that this is a Pakistani phenomenon,” Fair says. “As we all know, there is Pakistani involvement. There is recruitment across the border. In the tribal areas, madrasas figure prominently. But even if Pakistan went away, you still have a largely Afghan-driven insurgency.” Fair describes the situation as a “cross-border phenomenon,” and says that “the insurgency is not going to be resolved if you think that the problem stops either at one side or the other of the Afghan border.”

Her findings are supported by a series of interviews with Taliban fighters in Kandahar Province that was published online last month by Canada’s The Globe and Mail newspaper. Those interviews suggest NATO air strikes and drug-eradication programs have fed the insurgency in southern Afghanistan. Many Taliban soldiers said their family members had been killed in air strikes or that they had been opium-poppy farmers until their crops were destroyed by drug-eradication teams.

Paul Fishstein, the director of the Afghan Research and Evaluation Unit, an independent Kabul-based research organization that receives funding from the United Nations, the European Commission, and other international donors, says that researchers should be careful not to oversimplify the demographics of today’s Taliban. “We always have to be careful about referring to ‘The Taliban,’” Fishstein says. “Often, anything violent — anything bad that happens — is attributed to either ‘the enemies of Afghanistan’ or, more generally, ‘The Taliban.’”

Fishstein concludes that the structure of today’s Taliban is complex — and that foreign researchers often have difficulty understanding the rivalries and local agendas that have contributed to the resurgence of the movement. “What we generically refer to as ‘The Taliban’ is a set of different individuals and groups who have differing grievances, differing motivations, differing attitudes — and take a hostile attitude toward the Afghan government,”

According to Fishstein: “There’s an awful lot of groups out there that either have personal grudges, political grudges, or actually profit from the lack of law and order in the country.”

While these are chilling factors the other storm of chill arise out of groupings of the forces in Afghanistan and Pakistan. The Afghan Taliban, whatever its structure may be, is firmly aligned to Osama bin Laden’s al Qaeda. The TTP factions and other Pakistani Jihadi tanzeems are loosely aligned to this conglomerate. It is a Global Jihad Inc. The joint force has emerged as an ideology:

    Politics of Religion and Revival of Original Islam of the period of the Prophet and fresh expansion of the forces of Islam in all the countries of all the continents. Export of ideology is easier than deputing physical forces. Britain’s recent realization that all terrorist activities in the country lead to Pakistan is a painful confession of free export of al Qaeda and Taliban ideology.

Besides this grouping, the TTP have collaborative relationship with Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jais-e-Mohammad, Lashkar-Jhangvi, Jamait-ul Mujahideen (Pak) and Hijbul Mujahideen. These forces are available at the command of Taliban, TTP and the ISI to extend operations in India and Bangladesh. Recent emergence of Hezbullah (in Bogra) in Bangladesh spells newer dangers for South Asia. This is the restructured International Council for Jihad. While these forces are partners of the TTP for occupation of Pakistan, the TTP itself is aligned to the Afghan Taliban and al Qaeda. This comprehensive picture should be able to open the blinded eyes and dead soul of Pakistan.

Unfortunately Pakistan is yet to wake up despite repeated visits by high US officials and announcement of flooding Pakistan with money, honey and military bonhomie. President Zardari, PM Giliani and other lesser politicians indulge in ambivalence like the canine cutie singing into the megaphone of the armed forces and the ISI. Even if it is assumed that conscious section of the civil society of Pakistan is against Talibanisation and the democratic forces do not want politics of religion the Army, ISI and the forces of Islam germinated by Zia-ul-Haq and nurtured by the mullhas and maulanas and flowered by the jihadi tanzeems (fathered by the ISI) are likely to devour the political existence of Pakistan. The State of Pakistan is likely to very soon surrender to Politics of Religion and International Protocol of Islamic Jihad.

The Army does not want to engage the TTP, al Qaeda and other tanzeems on geostrategic consideration that in case the practitioners of politics of religion are weeded out they would lose the services of an Auxiliary Army that is being used to bleed the USA and the NATO in Afghanistan, and India in Kashmir and in its heartland. Pakistan has used such Auxiliary Army against India in 1948 and 1965 (Kashmir) and is using again in Kashmir and other parts of India. Pakistan has been transformed into a factory of Sahidee Dasta- suicide squads producing facility. By spending a paltry amount of 100,000 they can produce a human bomb that is capable of wrecking havoc.

The US has been caught in Catch 22 situation. It cannot sustain the war in Afghanistan without Pakistan’s help. With full knowledge of Pakistan Army the Taliban is regularly burning US convoys carrying war materials to Afghanistan. Now the CAR countries and Russia are opening up routes and air bases to help the NATO forces; so much so that the US now badly wants Russia to jump into the Afghan war. What an irony of history; the same US had strengthened the ISI, created mujahideen and al Qaeda to defeat the USSR in Afghanistan. Would Afghanistan and Pakistan be another killing ground of global democracy and secularism? Would the concept of politics of religion emerge victorious in this region and spread in other parts of the world? These questions would continue to haunt the world till the present fabrics of Pakistan’s jihadi forces are not destroyed and the civil societies in Afghanistan and Pakistan are restored and democracy is mad vibrant. For achieving this goal the USA has to defang the rogues in Pakistan Army, bureaucracy and the ISI.
Painfully, the situation is drifting out of control. According to Dr Hasan-Askari Rizvi, a political commentator of Pakistan, “the overall disposition of the official and non-official circles towards terrorism is generally ambiguous, and they lack the much-needed unity of mind on the threat of terrorism. Most condemn terrorism and view it as a threat to Pakistan; however, many of them would not name a militant group for an incident or would not favour the application of tough measures against the perpetrators of terror.
The typical Pakistani mindset is oriented to religious conservatism and militancy and shows varying degrees of sympathy for militants. Naturally, such a mindset cannot be easily convinced that the Taliban and Al Qaeda are a genuine threat to Pakistan.

Suicide bombings and other terrorist attacks are typically described as nothing more than reactions to American military presence in Afghanistan or revenge for American drone attacks in the tribal areas. The argument is that Pakistan’s security forces are killing the tribal people at the behest of the US, which causes anger among the Taliban, who in turn target Pakistani state institutions and public places for retribution. The typical line of thought that runs quite deep in official civilian and military circles is what else can one expect from the Taliban when Pakistan and the US bomb their homes.


This mindset describes terrorist attacks as a US, Indian and Israeli conspiracy to destabilise Pakistan. The US wants to destabilise Pakistan in order to justify taking over Pakistan’s nuclear weapons and making it subservient to India. This skewed mental and emotional disposition has been created not only by madrassa education but also by the regular state education system, starting in the mid-1980s under the Zia regime. Zia-ul Haq’s government also used state patronage to promote Islamist groups and militancy, and the media was also used to propagate Islamic orthodoxy and militancy.

The socialisation of young people along these lines continued even after the death of Zia-ul Haq. The military, the ISI and their Islamist allies continued with the Zia legacy. A halfhearted attempt was made by General Pervez Musharraf after September 2001 to change this Islam- oriented socialisation but his desire to win over the MMA for political survival diluted this effort… Religious extremism and terrorism are now threatening civic order and security in varying degrees in the NWFP, Punjab and Sindh. In Balochistan, Taliban-type groups have a strong presence in and around Quetta, which has transformed the religio-cultural profile of the area.

Hard-line militant groups, the Taliban and others based in mainland Pakistan, appear to have gained confidence after the peace agreement in Swat and the spate of high-profile terrorist attacks in Lahore, Islamabad and Chakwal. The Tehreek-e Taliban Pakistan threatened to launch two such attacks a week.” Can Pakistan cope with terrorism? Daily Times 12.04.09. The same fears were earlier expressed by Nazam Sethi, editor Daily and Friday Times in an editorial titled “The state has given up” on 05.04.2009.

This being the candid view of a Pakistani political analyst can India remain safe if Pakistan is occupied by Taliban and al Qaeda and allied tanzeems? An examination of the helplessness of Pakistan indicates that jihad has the tendency to overflow national boundaries. Additionally the Ummah concept does not recognize and national or state boundary. India is just in the pathway of Jihad twister now ravaging Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Political map Pakistan, Compare Infobase Limited

Political map Pakistan, Compare Infobase Limited


Places of Action by TTP and al Qaeda in Pakistan.

The illustration above makes it clear that Taliban elements are very much present on Swat, Waziri and ‘Azad Kashmir’ borders, even up to Manshera. Even if some reports of presence of TTP in Muzaffarabad are not correct it should be taken into account that late Commander Khalid’s group of TTP was earlier operating in Kashmir in different name. There are confirmed reports that the TTP has shifted closer to AJK, at Manshera, Sial, Kot Bhalla, Lasu Sultani, Thandiani, Balakot (NWFP) areas. From these stations the TTP can reach Muzaffarbad in 24 hours.

Can Pakistan use the TTP as an Auxiliary Army in Indian Kashmir? Your author has reliable information that a section of Pakistan Army and the ISI are bribing the TTP to cease operations in Swat and North and South Waziri areas and divert action into IHK-‘Indian Held Kashmir.’ It is a matter of time when Pakistan would use US money to deploy the combined forces of the TTP, L-e-T, J-e-M, J-u-M Pak and Hizb-ul-Mujahideen. Their operations are obviously not likely to remain confined to J&K. The target is Indian heartland.
The question is: Can India cope with the situation if Pakistan deploys the combined forces of the TTP and allied tanzeems? At this point of time the answer is: NO, a big NO.

Since 26/11 very little has changed except certain uncertain pronouncements by the Union Home Minister and the Prime Minister. The UPA government has bluffed the people of India. What is being said in election rallies are nothing but electoral mud and mass placebo. Informed sources in the government say that nothing new has been done to strengthen the Central IB. What has really been done is approval of the government to fill up 6000 vacancies for which approval was given by NDA government but never administratively implemented because of Ministry of Finance setting up roadblocks. The Home and the Prime Minister and the UPA chief did very little to expedite the process. They have misled the people by offering false promises. Now there is a hesitant rush to reemploy some retired IB officers (for maximum 5 years only) and get some police and army personnel on deputation (negligible). New recruitment takes to prepare a supposed batch of 100 officers (annual capability to train) to deploy in the field as intelligence generators a minimum period of 5 years. So, to fill up 6000 vacancies in cutting edge level of intelligence gathering the IB would take minimum 10 years. Why the government is trying to fool the countrymen? The entire process of the UPA government gearing up for combating serious threat from Pakistani Auxiliary Army is a charade. The country is being bluffed.

The State Governments with some exceptions of Gujarat and Kerala and Andhra Pradesh, have done precious little to create Exclusive Intelligence Branches with dedicated officers. Creation of Strike Forces-Task Forces-Commandos etc are for battle engagement. Who generates the essential intelligence input? There is NONE. The State governments are not serious on the issue of creating dedicated Intelligence Units with wider ground spread.

A lot was said about coastal security after 26/11. What has been done in last 5 odd months? Nothing or very little. As of today nothing tangible is visible on the ground. Barring some preparedness in J&K no tangible preparations have been made anywhere in the mainland India. Mere absence of 26/11 like incidents during the lull period does not mean that the Jihadis in Pakistan have gone on summer hibernation and their collaborators in India have rushed to the mango gardens (the luscious season is coming). Not more than 3 jihadi cells have been busted in last 5 months. If the NSA is to be believed there are more than 800 cells in India. It is not mandatory for the government to share secret information. But the way organs of the government responsible for National Intelligence and Security should have more open windows to reassure the people. The Establishment should share information with the public. It is the constitutional right of the people.

India has the bitter lesson that Pakistan is not going anywhere with the 26/11 investigation. The CCPO Lahore has already blamed India for the Lahore attack on Sri Lanka cricket team. Pakistani leaders are articulating every day India’s involvement with the Baloch insurgents and some segments of the TTP. With such mental blockade of Pakistan India can expect very little cooperation. All said and done the USA is not likely to bail out India.

Should India align with the US to combat the Taliban and al Qaeda? No. The US cannot do without its nemesis-Pakistan and final desertion of Afghanistan/Pakistan leaving the region open to Islamic Jihad. Obama is not Bush who would jump into action against Pakistan, especially when the US is passing through 1929-30 like recession. The NATO would be happy if they are allowed to withdraw from Afghanistan. The US allies in Iraq are tired and want to withdraw. The US does not dare to attack Bush’s ‘Axis of Evil’ even though North Korea gains ICBM capability and Iran is on the verge nuclear breakthrough.

On the other hand, the Islamsit forces are gaining strength in Western China (ironically China has reached a protocol with Jamait-e-Islami Pakistan and the pro-TTP government of NWFP), Chechnya, Dagestan, Ingushetia (all in Russian Federation), Germany, Sweden, Norway, France, Spain and the UK. Recent researches indicate that al Qaeda network exists in about 150 places in the USA. In Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Somalia, Sudan, Egypt (home of al Zawahiri), Algeria, Tunisia and Morocco etc countries al Qaeda has been emerging as reckonable forces. Al Qaeda influence affects the jihadi tanzeems in Bangladesh, Indonesia and the Philippines. This being the global picture, India, with nearly 800 jihadi modules still to be identified should not be drawn into the dragnet of US global strategy.

India is required to develop its own strategy based on the principles constant war preparedness. This is not going to be a frontal war. The al Qaeda and Taliban have introduced a new guerrilla war tactics that can thwart any conventional army. India should be prepared for anti-guerrilla warfare in its very heartland, besides Kashmir and the Northeast. To achieve capability India cannot remain complacent by false and exaggerated promises by the so-called secular Congress & casteist allies (UPA?) and much maligned so-called Hindu Right Wing Reactionary Communal Forces (NDA?). The people are no more ready to be fooled by false and provocative hyperboles. Some real ground level war preparedness is called for. And that should be now. Otherwise India would miss the opportunity and can only bemoan when a Talibanised Pakistan decides to deploy its Auxiliary Army to Indian theatres. That time is not far.


Comments

94 Responses to “The Warriors of Allah”

  1. A HINDU
    April 15th, 2009 @ 8:39 am

    Thank you sir for presenting very informative piece. I am shocked to know that HM, PM and Sonia have not done anything ecept giving false promises. How can we stop the march of taliban when they have established bases in Pak Punjab? We are the next natural target. The US, Afghanistan have objected to Pak surrender to Taliban. Why is not India lodgint protest? Are we so imbecile? Why should we vote for Congress if the PM bluffs us?  

  2. Bentham Fisher
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:01 am

    Excellent Mr. Dhar. This is a comprehensive and in depth study. I wonder why Pakistani politicians are succumbing to Taliban? What is India doing? Can’t India join US and pressure Pakistan?

  3. chintamani sharma
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:08 am

    Welcome Dhar. Your research is incisive. But where do we stand when HM, PM and Sonia bluff us? How do we fight al Qaeda and Taliban and the other Auxiliary Armies of Pakistan? What is our psychophant doormat NSA doing?

  4. Dharmendra Raj
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:09 am

    Your analysis is good. You have projected the problem well. But please suggest what should we do with imbecile governments misleading us?

  5. Faqir Asakzai
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:11 am

    Oi kafir Hindustani! How dare you take the name of the Allah? We are sure to storm India in near future. We will direct our boys to take care of you, a Satan. Be aware, you enemy of Islam.

  6. Ehasanullah Torikhel
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:17 am

    TU KAFIR HINDUSTANI! HOW DARE YOU TO MALIGN THE HOLY NAME OF ALLAH THE ALMIGHTY? YES WE ARE SOLDIERS OF ALLAH AND WE WILL CARRY THE MESSAGE OF ISLAM TO ALL KAFIRS AND IMPOSE SHARIA ON HINDUS ALSO. YOU HINDUS ARE GODLESS INSECTS. IT IS ALLAH’S ORDER TO KIILL ALL JAHIL KAFIRS. WE ARE COMING. 

  7. BrainDead
    April 15th, 2009 @ 11:02 am

    You can storm India. You all are welcome. We are not Pakis that you will storm us.  Could heve been better titled “Assholes of Allah!”

  8. Dravid
    April 15th, 2009 @ 11:35 am

    Oh Pleeeeaze come.  Even Allah will not take you back after you meet me. I will prepare 72 virgin female donkeys for you since 72 homosexuals will not be available in your hell.

  9. Mandar Koplekar
    April 15th, 2009 @ 4:54 pm

    SIR, THIS IS A VERY INFORMATIVE AND FRIGHTENING ARTICLE. PAKISTAN IS NOT WILLING TO FIGHT THE TALIBAN. INDIA SHOULD PREPARE NOW. BUT AS YOU SAY OUR POLITICIANS KEEP BLUFFING THE PEOPLE. WHAT SHALL WE DO?

  10. Baitullah Sherkhan Taliki
    April 15th, 2009 @ 4:59 pm

    You nharami kafir Hindustani. Tu kya socta hai? Hum Allah ke bande. oure duniya hamare kabze mei  hi ayaega. kya kar lega tu Hindi log? Hum Hindukush me rahte hai, jahan Hinduonka qabr khoda gaya tha. Fiqr mat kar. Hum aa rahe hain kafiron ki qatl karne.

  11. Saifur Peerzada
    April 15th, 2009 @ 5:08 pm

    You are a Pakistan and Muslim hater. You have maligned my Jhang area. Remember Qasab is from Jhang. We Jhangis are great fighters. One of us equals 10 Indian soldiers. You civil Hindus are our slaves. We are coming soon at the head of Lashkar-e-Jhangvi.

  12. Sayiid Akhtar Ahmad
    April 15th, 2009 @ 6:12 pm

    A fine article sir. We have reasons to worry. Indian Muslims, barring the mullah fringe, would not like to live under Talibans. Let the Pakistanis be happy with their mullhas and let Pak women enjoy the lashing and bullets.

  13. Bidisha Meena
    April 15th, 2009 @ 6:16 pm

    An illuminating article. India is required to be prepared for the worst. Pakistan is on the verge of  surrendering to Taliban. Can we really depend on what politicians promise about our security?

  14. Dravid
    April 15th, 2009 @ 6:26 pm

    Baitullah Sherkhan Taliki,

    Tu allah ka banda? HAHAHAHAHHA! Tu allah ke naam pe Dhandha karta hai. Roti nahi kama sakta to allah ke naam pe badmashi kar raha hai. Kya kar loga tom Allah ke dhande walle log? Tum Hindukush ya jhannum me raho, hame iss se kya farak padta hai? kisi ne pucha tha kya? Aaja bacchu agar  tu ne aapne maa ka dudh piya hai!

    Saifur Peerzada
    ,

    You are not Jangi, you are Bhangi. You are from Lashkar-e-Bhangi. Khasab is a kafir, one bullet in his hand  and he pissed in his pants. Then he was beaten up by civil Hindu masters.

  15. Bharat Das
    April 15th, 2009 @ 7:56 pm

    Here is a news from Afghanistan

    “The law, passed last month, says a husband can demand sex with his wife every four days unless she is ill or would be harmed by intercourse — a clause that critics say legalizes marital rape.”

    Here is what how the news in Pakistan look like

    “The law, passed last month, says a husband can demand sex with his Male wife every four days unless he is ill or would be harmed by intercourse — a clause that critics say legalizes marital rape.”

    I see Paki Mu-Slimes pipe dreaming on this story too.

  16. Suganya
    April 15th, 2009 @ 9:10 pm

    Great article sir.The people of India should know what type of threat India faces now apart from the ISI sponcered terrorism which Pakistan has been using since 1956 against India as  a foreign policy.Pakistan is a declared Muslim state.And if Muslims are spreading terrorism,each and every one has the full right to Gun point them.This is a very worrisome situation for India.Unless we revoke Inder Gujral Doctrine of 1997 and start having covert operational policy against pakistan,there is no hope.because USA won’t gonna support us full heartedly in any case related to Pakistan.We need to take some step.R&AW has to do it with MOD.

  17. Rabindra Nayek
    April 16th, 2009 @ 8:47 am

    You have again enlightened us. We realise that TTP, al Qaeda and other ISI created militant groups are one and the same. They are ready to take over Pak and than march on to India.
    If the HM, PM, Sonia etc bluff us about opur security preparations than where do we stand? Is it time for dumping these political bandits and call in the Army? We are endangered because of incompetence of squabbling NPA. Let Congress go to hell. We require greater vigil on our fifth column, the subverted Muslims.

  18. Tariq Aziz Rampuri
    April 16th, 2009 @ 8:52 am

    Nayek, it is wrong to suspect Indian Muslims. We are Indians first and Muslim is our religious identity. We are against Pakistani machinations and Sharia laws. Let us remove old prejudices. If some Muslims have been subverted the State would take care of the deviants.

  19. Tarannum Sohail
    April 16th, 2009 @ 8:56 am

    This is a timely warning from Dhar. I enjoy your writing. This is the time for the country to unite and prepare fighting Pakistani Auxiliary Armies. Forget we are Muslims and Hindus. WE are Indians.

  20. Taba Tabi Mehsud
    April 16th, 2009 @ 8:59 am

    Dhar, you bloody Kashmiri is against our blood. You should know that the Mehsud is the biggest tribe in NWFP. We would take care of you. We do not pardon any jahil kafir. The Sikhs living in our area had to pay 20 million rupee Jiziya. WE will finish you and impose Jizuiya on all the HIndustani Dhimmis. Days are not far when Mehsud Sultanate will rule from Delhi.

  21. Salim Sahzad
    April 16th, 2009 @ 9:06 am

    You are chronic anti Pakistani. We in Punjab do not see Taliban as an evil. We Punjabis are determined to get back what bloody India had denied to Pakistan during partition. We want entire Punjab and Gujarat and part of Rajasthan and obviously Kashmir is ours. If Taliban delivers Kashmir to us we are ready to be ruled by them.

  22. chintamani sharma
    April 16th, 2009 @ 9:07 am

    These Pakistani imbeciles are giving empty threat. Go ahead Dhar. We are with you.

  23. Arvi
    April 16th, 2009 @ 9:50 am

    “We want entire Punjab and Gujarat and part of Rajasthan and obviously Kashmir is ours.”
    Yeah yeah you might even want New Delhi. Doesn’t mean diddly squat.

    “If Taliban delivers Kashmir to us we are ready to be ruled by them.”
    Oh puhlease. Are you a 5 year old kid? Because if you are not you should be given the DARWIN AWARD for the stupidest person on Earth. The Taliban are the same morons who practically ruled Afg but couldn’t keep it. Not to mention they are DUMB AS DOORKNOBS (with due apologies to doorknobs). And you are saying they are a threat to Indian Army (GIMME A BREAK). How are these yahoos any different from LeT or JeM that are Punjabi based ? So are you saying that Pakhtuns are braver than Punjabis? Well that would explain the 71 surrender I guess. In any case, the “bravery” of these guys is a joke. It only seems to be against 17 year old teenage girls and innocent music CD shopkeepers. Stupid cavemen.

    Anyway your statement reminded me of an old Metallica song (called King Nothing).

    “Careful what you wish
    careful what u say
    careful what u wish u MAY REGRET it
    careful what u wish u JUST MIGHT GET it
    Then it ALL CRASHES DOWN
    AND YOU BREAK YOUR CROWN
    And u point ur finger but there is no one around”

  24. Arvi
    April 16th, 2009 @ 10:01 am

    Oh come on. These bunch of cavemen are now gonna take over Pindi, Karachi, Isloo and Lawhore. And what are the whiskey-sipping jernails in Pak Army and ISI gonna do meanwhile? Pluck flowers? GIMME A BREAK. Plus where are all these Talebs getting their resources from? Who is giving them money? They themselves have money? Yeah right my grandma told me better stories that were more realistic in my childhood days.

    I think this is a tactical ploy by ISI + PA. They are being pressurized by Unkil. A LOT. So think of this as “strategic depth” in reverse. This way Pak will seem to be too preoccupied with internal issue and get a “stay” on Unkil’s matters. Plus it will now say “Not only Afg we are also a victim of terror onlee”. Plus it will use internal instability to get more aid from Unkil (govrnmand will say if Pak “falls” Talebs hold the nuke button so give more money for us to finish off the Talebs). Finally, these Taleb yahoos will also help Pak when Unkil leaves Afg and Unkil WILL LEAVE SOONER OR LATER!! So four mangoes with one stone.

  25. Juman Sarhadi
    April 16th, 2009 @ 12:46 pm

    We Muslims want to be ruled by our religious law-Sharia. Wewant sharia rule for all Muslims all over world-Hindu bewokoof jahil kafirs included. Islam should be the State religion of India. You Dhar, stupid Kashmiri, we will make you read the Qalma and bend before the Allah, or you pay with your life for abusing the purest of pure Talibans.

  26. Jaswant Thakre
    April 16th, 2009 @ 12:47 pm

    Hello brave Talibans! Come to India and we will emasculate you and consign you to the realm of your Damn Allah ro dance and dine with 59,000 Huris. Go to hell!

  27. Kamaljit Singh Sandhu
    April 16th, 2009 @ 12:50 pm

    I am sorry to hear that Sikhs living in Swat had to pay 20 million rupee to the Taliban as Jiziya for living and doing business there. I call upon the Akali Dal, SGPC and Government of India to take up the matter with Pakistan government. How can Pak make minorities to pay Jiziya? In that case we have to impose ces on India Muslims.

  28. Laxman Bahutule
    April 16th, 2009 @ 12:53 pm

    Funny! These bearded animals called Taliban wants to enslave the Hindus and kill Dhar! Let us prepare Hindu Lashkars and kill as many Paki Muslims as possible. The eunuch Mullah Talibans should be dehumanised by severing their vital parts. 

  29. Dipack Hattengdi
    April 16th, 2009 @ 2:32 pm

    Hats off to you MKD for telling the ‘truth’ and calling a spade a spade. As I a Kemalist I completely agree with your ‘nationalistic’ (it has not been in vogue since 1947) views. Vatan-e-Hind (no reference to Hindu), Sarvapratham, Sarvashrestah always. Be well, Sir. As for our enemies of many hues both internal and external, Kill em all, let God sort them out!!

  30. Shital Gandhi
    April 16th, 2009 @ 2:53 pm

    To arvi:

    Dear first read and percept what the writer wish to know all and then react.  its seems you diverted from the discipline how to talk and  shows your immature ability to understand the subject. You are still in the jinx of Sriram Sene……Literate yourself and them come on forum…..

  31. Kumar
    April 16th, 2009 @ 3:26 pm

    Sir,
    The incoming government will most likely have its hands full when it assumes office after the general elections. As of now there is no policy in place to tackle the emerging security threat from across the border. With Taliban sweeping Pakistan, India’s  security scenario will undergo a sea change. I don’t see the Armed forces tackling small-time incursions or infiltrations. It will be a case of suicide bombers and more deadly fidayeen attacks. Fighting battles on this side of the LOC may only embolden this new deadly breed of terrorists. We can no longer depend on US, West or international community to combat this kind of terror. Sir, more in my email.
    Regards

  32. Rahamatullah Kakakhel
    April 16th, 2009 @ 6:29 pm

    Tu harami Hindustani hamari Orakzai, Bajaur biradari ko Taliban samajh kar guna kar raha hai. Hum Talibani pure duniya ko kabze me layaenge. Kya kar liya tera harami america ahghanistan me? Kya kar lega Pakistan me? Pakistan duniya ke upar raj karega aur deeni taj sar pe rakhega. Bachna cahate to Islam apna lo. Nahi to maut tere liye intzar kar rahi hai, tu kafir Hinndustani.  

  33. abhishek
    April 17th, 2009 @ 2:52 am

    Dear Shital Gandhi.Practice what you preached, and read before you shoot.
    Arvi, it is clear to most, attempted to silence the tub-thumping, hate-spewing Talibs who were swearing to kill Indians and make you suffer for who they are. 
    He used sarcasm and a logic to shut up these threatening louts. You have problems with that?
    I won’t get into whether he could be a Ram Sene follower or you a paragon of secularism..But it would suffice to say it’s about India here and the threats we face from terror, including from across the border.
    If You can’t grasp what the author wrote about, then you beter use your political rhetoric at an appropriate place, say, a municipal election, a to begin with. 

  34. Arvi
    April 17th, 2009 @ 3:50 am

    “Hum Talibani pure duniya ko kabze me layaenge.”

    Dude like I said u dumb idiots couldn’t even rule Afg that was already 90% destroyed by the Russians in first place. And u dream of ruling the world!! Yeah right. Pakistani punjabis are always full of bluster but when it comes to crunch they shamelessly surrender just like in 71.

  35. Khidmat-e-Jihad
    April 17th, 2009 @ 11:14 am

    Bimillah ur Rahman e Rahim.
    You are incorrigible Dhar. Last time I had warned you to desist from maligning the servants of the Allah. Now you have again written bad things about them. We are Mussalmans, we have separate sets of laws-The Quran, Sharia, Hadith. We live by that. You slave Indians do not disturb us, else we would silence you.

  36. Mohan Kalita
    April 17th, 2009 @ 12:56 pm

    Sir, you should revisit Assam. Here the Muslim UG organisations are in cahoot with ULFA and NDFB and DHD in North Cachar Hills. Muslim immigrants are so politically powerful that they can make and unmake a government. Congress is behaving as enemy of the Hindus.

  37. Shital
    April 17th, 2009 @ 3:38 pm

    To Abhhishek

    Dear i knew why  arvi wrote the responce…ist absolutely clear bash  to mullahs who r still in stiff denial mode on this forum . while  its  acid test to depict out what fuming in our cerebrum under the shanti fibre of secularism and extent of  the point at which it will explode..i get my answer.

  38. neeraj kale
    April 17th, 2009 @ 11:38 pm

    dear sir,
                     spledid article, ahmed rashid is rite pakistan will “descent into chaos”. hopefully uncle sam will have the presence of mind to take over the nuke facilites if such a dire situation ever arises. then we can launch our own army into pakistan. but this is a real long shot. my heart goes out to the liberal and educated pakistanis, they will have to really suffer. i guess this is the sunni version of iranian revolution. except for taliban is more brutal. 
    we indians need to be really aware, except british all invaders of india have come from the khyber pass 

  39. neeraj kale
    April 17th, 2009 @ 11:42 pm

    dear sir,
                    we are all aware of taliban’s anti shia stance, 20 percent of pakistan is shia. taking this fact in to mind will taliban be able to garner enough support to take over islamabad? is pakistan on brink of civil war?

  40. Arvi
    April 18th, 2009 @ 3:59 am

    “The question is: Can India cope with the situation if Pakistan deploys the combined forces of the TTP and allied tanzeems? At this point of time the answer is: NO, a big NO.”

    Oh, please you gotta be kidding me. How are these TTP any different from LeT or JeM (for the 99,999th time LeT is NOT a Kashmiri group, it is a Punjabi group, it is based out of Muridke near Lawhore). If the Army can manage the 60 year insurgency (tell me any other Army in the world that has managed an insurgency the size of Kashmir for over 60 years), you think these cavemen are gonna come and defeat them. Yeah right!! First let them topple Pak govt. nay even Peshawar then we will see.

  41. Arvi
    April 18th, 2009 @ 4:17 am

    Mr. Dhar seems to have fallen for Taliban and AQ (though he has not realized it) when he calls TTP and Baitullah Mehsud “warriors of Allah”. This is what these takfiri idiots call themselves and the author by acknowledging has directly played into their hands. Instead of calling these ragtag milita groups from the Stone Ages precisely that, he conflates their strength by calling them “warriors of Allah” and makes it implicitly a fight against Islam. It is not. What gives these takfiri idiotsthe right to be spokesmen of Islam?

    This behavior is similar to this statement that I heard from a friend of mine the other “Taliban will soon takeover Pak and this will have spillover effects in the madrassahs within India thereby increasing the risk of India becoming an Islamic state”. Utter NONSENCE!! It is equating Indian Muslims with Pakistanis (just because of their religion) and is an insult to millions of patriotic Muslims in India. Not only that, it is the Hindu sense of insecurity that makes him say this (Yeah I know I am stereotyping and generalizing a bit with just one Hindu response but I see similar article even in the news media e.g. Rediff saying things like “Beware of Indian Taliban”). In fact such kind of thinking, that “all Muslims are the same and hence should come under one Caliphate” is what AQ believes in. So my friend seems to have fallen for the AQ ideology (atleast the first part).

    In fact, Darul Uloom Deoband was one of the first madrassahs to openly condemn terrorism and issue a fatwa against it.
    Muslims can be Shia, Ahmadiya, Barelvi, Deobandi, Salafi, Wahabbi, Ismaili, Alawite, Sufi and many more. And no, they are all not the same.

  42. Arvi
    April 18th, 2009 @ 4:29 am

    And what is with this “bravery” of the Taliban?? This is a myth propagated especially by Western media (yeah yeah i know about the Russians leaving Afg but attributing it primarily to the mujahedins would be a mistake; it was primarily due to ECONOMIC COLLAPSE that Russia left Afg, anyways most of those “commanders” are now either dead or into retirement). Flogging a teenage girl or hanging an innocent music CD shopkeeper from the lamppost are hardly acts of bravery. And even if they are brave (this is a BIG IF) they will be just cannon fodder for Indian Army due to their stupidity.

    I think Gen. Deepak Kapoor neatly summed up in 1 sentence when asked about the Taliban “threat”:
    “Whether it is Lashkar-e-Taiba, Jaish-e-Muhammad or Harkatul Jahadul Islami militants or Taliban, whosoever tries to disturb peace, will be dealt with in the same fashion”
    You know what dealing with means, right? Because Indian Army believes that
    “Forgiving a terrorist is God’s responsibility
    Arranging a meeting between God and him is our responsibility

  43. Arvi
    April 18th, 2009 @ 5:14 am

    The Taliban seem to have institutional support (in Pak there is only institution that is worth anything and that is the ISI plus PA combo; there are no “rogue” ISI agents like there are no “rogue” military men). Okay if we get are clear on that, then it is obvious there will be no Taliban “takeover” (even if this is not true there will be no takeover because if u know a bit about Pak u know that Pak Army directly or indirectly controls 70% of GDP; it owns huge amounts of land from which it provides retired jernails like Hamid Gul with mansions; though after Zia there has been a reduction but still there are a large number of whiskey-sipping jernails, I am told Kiyani likes his Scotch shaken, not stirred just like double-oh-seben jee etc. etc. Okay so why is ISI (and obviously by implication PA) helping these Talebs gain control in FATA and NWFP (already Taleban is in control in Malakhand and Bunner by some accounts, but remember though this is a “takeover” there has been very little casualty from both sides). I can think of 4 reasons.

    1. There was some genuine Pakhtun nationalism and also people were getting vexed with the drone attacks. Now these goons like TTP are being used to instil fear into the people to make them obedient.
    2. Pak Army would like a LOT of aid from Unkil. Now a sensible person would say “Ah but the Americans surely are not gonna fall for this”. I am not gonna go into detail on this but sufficeto say that given Pak’s history the person is underestimating Pak’s ability to negotiate while pointing a gun to its own head (now there are even nukes do no forget) and of course American ignorance in foreign policy.
    3. Pak Army has always been interested in “strategic depth” inside Afg. But now since they are finding it difficult to get under Karzaid they are GIVING strategic depth to Taleban. Also this helps when Afghans and Karzai come down hard on them because now they will say “We too are a victim of terrorism by Taleban”a tactic that has been used pretty well against India judging by the fact that even our adharaniya purvi pradan mantriji (one hopes he does not return for the next term) seems to have fallen for it.
    4. Pak Army and ISI realizes (rightfully??) that Unkil is sooner or later gonna leave Afg and are already equipping their “strategic depth” providers (though judging by the past these idiots squandered the advantage they had in Afg) for the scenario in the aftermath.

    So like my grandma says 4 mangoes with one stone. Of course we all know ISI can be tactically superb but commit a strategic blunder (remember the surrender of 71 where Indian victory was more or less guaranteed due to the groundwork done by RAW). So never underestimate Pak stupidity.

    War preparedness is all fine. But that is not the key thing. Key thing is for India to understand the overall strategic perspective so that India can use the unfolding situation to her advantage like she did during the creation of Bangladesh (of course India squandered the opportunity by not staying in Bangladesh and shaping things to her advantage; nonetheless creation of Bangladesh was a great thing no doubt about that). What does the US want in Afg? What do Iran and Russia want? To what extent are the latter two especially Iran prepeared to go to prevent a non-Talibanized Afghanistan? These are the important questions India should focus on. India has a lot of stake (she has already given about $2B to the Afghans) in ensuring a stable and secure Afghanistan.

  44. Lesile Hanni
    April 18th, 2009 @ 8:21 am

    I am from Lebanon. We have our problems with Iran affiliated militant groups. We have Christian-Muslim dispute. However, we shudder to think Taliban like development in our country. It appears Indian subcontinent and Afghanistan and Iran have become hotbed of Muslim resurgence and they have taken to rotten fundamentalism. The entire free world should unite to destroy these forces. I wonder why USA and EU countries continue to fund Pakistan, when the leaders and the army have no intention to fight the Talibs and Osama.

  45. ethel cairn
    April 18th, 2009 @ 8:23 am

    My country US is stupid. Bush the foolish supported Pakistan and Obama, a hidden Muslim is supporting Pakistan with billions.  Why the EU are supporting Pakistan? Let the west declare total war with Pakistan with help from India and Israel.

  46. Kumar
    April 18th, 2009 @ 12:17 pm

    Arvi

    Darul ul Deoband may have condemned terrorism as anti-Islamic. But have they condemned the barbarity of the Taliban and the allied groups? NO. For the simple reason, most of the Islamic terrorists have been indocrinated in one or the other madrassas run by Deoband.  So let us not be fooled by pronouncements or declarations.

  47. Akhtar Hashim
    April 18th, 2009 @ 4:00 pm

    Pakistan is not going to evaporate even if there is a regime change_Taliban taking over. Pakistan is there to punish Hindu kafirs and rescue 20 crore Muslims imprisoned in India. We, Bangladeshi and Indian Muslim would unite again and rule over the entire South Asia + Afghanistan.
    What can you do

  48. Zohar Abbasi
    April 19th, 2009 @ 8:41 am

    Dhar, you are spreading hatred against Pakistan and you are an enemy of Islam. Pakistan was born not only as home for the Muslims, it is also destined to be the arch spearhead of reoccupying Bharat for Islam. Hindus do not deserve freedom.

  49. Wasbir Qasab
    April 19th, 2009 @ 8:44 am

    Tu jahil kafir Hindu! Kya tera haisiat ki tu Musalmano ko chidta hai? Tu kaun kheti ki muli? Hum tereko nigal jayaenge. Chod Taliban Shaliban aapna bhagvan ka naam le. Akhir ghari aa hi gaya tera.

  50. Yarappa Chandragiri
    April 19th, 2009 @ 8:49 am

    An excellent article sir. I have now a total picture about Taliban and threat to India. Can I reprint it in our Telugu magazine Chandrakantha” Please mail me your permission.

  51. Brindavan Mathur
    April 19th, 2009 @ 5:11 pm

    A well documented and researched document. I enjoy reading your articles and book.

  52. Bushan Kumar
    April 19th, 2009 @ 5:14 pm

    It is an informative article sir. Where do we go from here? Western countries say Taliban would take over Pak in 6 months. Don’t we know that a talibani Pakistan  would have scant respect for international protocol. They would mount direct attack on India. Are we prepared?

  53. Baitullah Kurramzai
    April 19th, 2009 @ 5:17 pm

    STOP MALIGNING THE TALIBAN. TALIBANISM IS THE DIRECT DESCENDANT OF THE PROPHET. THEY ARE NOT POLLUTED WESTERNIZED DEMOCRATS. OURS IS ISLAMIC DEMOCRACY AND THERE IS HIGHER DEMOCRACY THAN ISLAM. FOR THE PAIN OF YOU LIFE, ALLAH KE WASTE STOP WRING GARBAGE.

  54. Indian
    April 19th, 2009 @ 5:55 pm

    Zohar Abbasi. By talking of killing, slaughtering and Hindus incessantly, YOU are proving yourself as the enemy of Islam. Islam, otherwise, is a peaceful, noble, sublime religion. It is getting a bad name cos of pipedreamers like you.
    You talk of occupying India and making Hindus servile? Do you have some shame? India cut your country into two halves in 1971, and hunted down every one of your soldiers that had sneaked into the Kargil heights like thieves. Had you guys and your NWFP would have been in India, its gallant soldiers and commandos would have smoked you out and showed you your place, which is the dustbin of history! 
    Had the Pakistani army been confident of even lasting a week against our army, it would not have had relied on bragging, fools like the jihadis! go check with them!

  55. BENGAL UNDER ATTACK
    April 19th, 2009 @ 10:30 pm

    Sir,

    A brilliant critical analysis as usual. However why did you skirt the issue of GHAZWATUL HIND, KHORASAN and BILAD-E-SHAM while you wrote this article.

    Don’t you feel these “weak” Hadiths have been used to further the spread of terror by the madaris and ISI to indoctrinate these mindless warriors of Allah.

  56. Chandrmani Nautiyal
    April 20th, 2009 @ 8:51 am

    A comprehensive study, I wish you write on Islamists in India and danger from within.

  57. Emmanuel Pedro
    April 20th, 2009 @ 8:55 am

    Dear Sir, It was a pleasure to visit your site. We in Spain and Portugal have the bitter memories of Muslim occupation. Now the African Arabs and Pakistanis are attacking us. I feel your warning about Taliban is timely. I am circulating in my blog site. would send you the URL.

  58. Fahim Khan Peshawari
    April 20th, 2009 @ 8:59 am

    You are deadly correct. We in Peshawar region are living under shadow of Taliban. My VDO shop was burnt down by the Talibans. Several Barbar shops have been closed. Women do not feel safe to go out without hijab. These Islami monkeys are bringing bank wild Arab desert days.

  59. Govind Karkare
    April 20th, 2009 @ 9:02 am

    Sir, your article has moved me. Your piece on 26/11 was superb and acted as a prop of courage to all of us. You would be surprised to know that it has been reprinted in Marathi in some local magazines. A few posters were pasted with the banner line of your articlele.

  60. Rajaratnam
    April 20th, 2009 @ 6:08 pm

    DEAR SIR, I AM THRILLED BY THE ARTICLE. LOTS OF INFO PUMPED IN. OUR AGENCIES MUST BE AWARE OF THESE DEVELOPMNENTS. ARE THEY DOING ANYTHING TO STOP PAKISTANI MARCH INTO INDIA? OR ARE WE GONING TO BE BATTERED LIKE 26/11. THESE CONGRESS DACOITS ARE AFTER MONEY ALONE. THEY HAVE NO LOVE FOR THE COUNTRY.

  61. Philip Thomas
    April 20th, 2009 @ 6:14 pm

    Thank you sir for the well structured expose on Taliban. The picture is clear. Islamabad may fall to Taliban unless Pak army goes whole hog for the mullahs. I think there is little hope for that. Half of the army is pro Talibani. You have sounded a timely warning. India should gear up defences now.  

  62. Riaz Haq
    April 20th, 2009 @ 10:27 pm

    Ironically, there are some parallels here between the violent Maoists movement in India and the Taliban militants in Pakistan, in spite of their diametrically opposed ideologies. Maoists say they are fighting for the rights of neglected tribal people and landless farmers, as are the Taliban in FATA and NWFP. Both movements have killed dozens of people, including security personnel, in the last few weeks. Both movements control wide swathes of territory in their respective countries.

    Given the underlying and growing resentment against the feudal/tribal power of a narrow and corrupt ruling elite in Pakistan, it is almost certain that Swat represents only the beginning of a bloody revolt in the rest of the country.

    It is also clear that the new generation of Pakistanis do not want to accept life under a feudal or tribal system that denies them basic human dignity. In the absence of significant economic growth (even the phenomenal 8% growth roughly equals 2.5m jobs), not enough jobs are being created for 3 million young people ready to join the work force each year, resulting in growing availability of recruits for terror outfits who pay them fairly well by local standards. According to Rand corporation estimates, the Taliban pay about $150 a month to each fighter, much higher than the $100 a month paid by the governments in the region. This fact has been amply illustrated by recent growth of the Punjabi Taliban who have been found recruited by terrorist groups for suicide bombings and violence within and outside Pakistan.

  63. Arvi
    April 21st, 2009 @ 7:02 am

    El Prezidente “10%” Zardari (word on the street is he is now 30% onlee) has now issued a call for help (SOS if u will) from China saying “Please help us fight this menace of terrorism from Afg Pak border”. Of course he also made a plea for extra money, defence equipments etc. etc. So this is all going to script exactly according to my suspicion. The BIGGEST question now is whether a lamppost is awaiting his return to Pak. If that happens it means Taliban movement has reached a TIPPING POINT (with support from Army against its own govt). If that does not then this whole Taliban is a tamasha jus to milk Unkil and other donors for more money, sorry to disappoint u Majid. I think it will be the latter because I think Zardari (being a shrewd Sindhi; Sindhis are street smart and enterprising group of people) has got his bases covered and wouldn’t have said what he said without consulting Kiyani and Pasha plus I think Pak jernails are too fond of their whiskey and makaan to give Talebs much of a leeway. But with Pak u can never be 100% sure what is going on (they are always tactially brilliant but lose the bigger strategy game like in Bangladesh). Time will tell. Watch this space.

  64. Arvi
    April 21st, 2009 @ 7:11 am

    With regards to Indian POV, the best case scenario is if this situation festers, what see-eye-a calls “chronic insurgeny”. That will make Pak govt. look inward to these issues and lose its focus on India at the same time guaranteeing there will be no takeover by the cavemen. Win-win for India.

    In case this insurgency does not hold and Talebs seem to be gaining an upper hand (which I highly doubt) then Pakhthunistan should be carved out of NWFP, FATA and southern Afghanistan. Punjab and Sindh will then be India’s “buffer states” against these cavemen. Just like good old medieval days except now that these “buffer states” are a separate nation (unlike medieval times) they would take much better care of their security.

  65. Salim Sahzad
    April 21st, 2009 @ 3:49 pm

    Being in Islamabad we feel the heat of the Taliban. The political structure is tottering and politicians are surrendering to Taliban and other forces. The army is divided. I think all Pakistanis do not want Talibanism. Most do not. But Pakistan is lapsing in chaos. You are correct.

  66. David Kullinan
    April 22nd, 2009 @ 10:58 am

    A very informative expose. Do you the USA would lose out in Afghanistan too?

  67. Emir Faqruddin
    April 22nd, 2009 @ 5:21 pm

    You are insulting Islam. Taliban is a part of Holy Mission. I warn you not to spread bad news about Taliban.

  68. Dravid
    April 24th, 2009 @ 8:21 am

    Emir Faqruddin ,

    Dhar sir is doing his holy job. Don’t talk nonsense about him or threatn him. In here we prefer Mr. dhars holy job than your holy job. If you want to threaten someone, don’t you have women is SWAT ?

  69. Sayiid Akhtar Ahmad
    April 24th, 2009 @ 5:05 pm

    I say again. Pakistan’s days are numbered. In moths it will be Taliban Land.? What would India do? Talibans are trying to enter India via Sund and Gujarat, Hope thr country is aware?

  70. Sartaj Sekhon
    April 25th, 2009 @ 8:35 am

    It is not a fun for border states like Punjab, Rajasthan and Gujarat. If Taliban takes over Pak we will face tremendous threats

  71. Arvi
    April 25th, 2009 @ 9:06 am

    #70
    “It is not a fun for border states like Punjab, Rajasthan and Gujarat. If Taliban takes over Pak we will face tremendous threats”

    As if they are not already from LeT, JeM and countless other jehadis in Pak. Remember every jehadi in Pak has links to ISI and yes, that includes “Taleban”.

    The way I’m seeing it looks like there might be a split within the PA between whiskey sipping jernails and the low to mid level officers in PA many of whom are ethnic Pakhtuns who are finding it difficult to kill their own brethren aka the Taliban. Inshallah that will be sweet and awesome. A coup within the Army!!

  72. Nazia Mamoon
    April 26th, 2009 @ 1:03 pm

    Sir namaskar ebong shobhobarsher abhinndan.
    Your article is very timely. In Bangla also we are under extreme pressure from Taliban, Qaeda affiliated jihad groups. Hope India would be able to stop this mythologicl menace.

  73. Jairam Srinivasan
    April 27th, 2009 @ 8:28 am

    Recent reports indicate Taliban is attacking main cities of Pak. How strong is our border vigil?

  74. laxman kutty
    April 27th, 2009 @ 3:38 pm

    Developments in Pakistan support your views. I think Jinnah did a big mistake by taking these frontier tribals in Pakistan, the areas should have been given over to Afghanistan and Durand Line should now be scrapped.

  75. JImbult Herkner
    April 28th, 2009 @ 11:15 am

    Mr. Dhar.
    Your piece on Taliban is very interesting. Writing from Lebanon. Disturbing news is that al Qaeda had started building groups in Muslim areas of my country.

  76. Idris dev bugti
    April 29th, 2009 @ 8:07 am

    I am a Baloch and for for the BLA against Pakistan. Do not be surprised my dev name. My ancestors were HIndu Baloch. The Taliban has also activated the Quetta area. On the other hand al Qaeda activists wit ISI support are operating in the upper mountains. We Baloch are oppsed to Taliban, Qaeda and Pakistan and want warm ties with India. 

  77. Mullah Rorikhel
    April 29th, 2009 @ 8:09 am

    Oi to harami Hindustani. Taliban duniya bhar khifat ki parcham laharsyega. Islam and Allh alone can deliver you infidels. Sabr kar. Hum aa rahe hain.

  78. Jiva pishnu.
    April 29th, 2009 @ 8:13 am

    Greetings from Indonesia. In India my Hindu name should have been Jeeva Bishnu. I appreciate the story and wish you write more about Jemma Islamiya in Indonesia and MORO Liberation Force of the Phillipines.

  79. Somadit Sangkarn
    April 30th, 2009 @ 8:25 am

    Greetings from southern Thailand. Your article refreshes our anguish about growing Mulim rebellion aided by Bangladesh, Pakistan, al Qaeda. Taliban is yet to come. But Pak hand may bring it.

  80. Arwinder Singh
    April 30th, 2009 @ 10:12 am

    I am surprised to see fear in most readers. There is around i think 40 Divisions of Indian Army. Let them worry about Taliban. For years and decades people feed Military and all their comforts. I am sure they can live upto their expectations for few weeks or months when time comes for it. I believe Military is for that purpose and not just for electioneering.

  81. Jaswant Thakre
    April 30th, 2009 @ 11:40 am

    Hello Arvinder,
    You have opened a Pandora’s Box. Military can fight militarily. What about the Muslim Quislings in India? Would they think like you do or they would (most) jump into the Islamicist Bandwagon. This should be bravely discuss. I would invite Dravid etc readers to come forward.

  82. Parvez Alam Pathan
    April 30th, 2009 @ 8:19 pm

    Harami Hindustani. Tera javan khich lunga, das golia dagenge tere upar. Insha Allah we will meet you and other Hindustanis very soon. Khyal kar qayamat ki.

  83. Dravid
    May 1st, 2009 @ 3:59 pm

    Military has not lived a comfy life as Arvinder puts it. Actually, there is no point discussing with Arvi or Arvinders. They think from their arse. 

  84. Baitullah Sherkhan Taliki
    May 2nd, 2009 @ 12:36 pm

    Shbbas, Marhabba! Tera dum hain. Par na to Osama na to Mehsud would spare you-the enemy of Islam. We wait what garbages and lies you wrie in your 10 th May article. Kuch to daro jahil. Islami saif would cut you into pieces.

  85. Dravid
    May 2nd, 2009 @ 9:29 pm

    Maloyji,

    Please write more on Taleban. Swine Flu is spreading. 

  86. Arvi
    May 2nd, 2009 @ 9:49 pm

    Looks like the US is trying to directly deal with the Pak military instead of this “civilian facade” of a govt. Simultaneously it has also opened up Track 2 discussions with someone who it really despises generally – Mian Nawaz Sharif sahab.  Also, you have Zardari and Karzai being summoned to DC (an ultimatum?? maybe. an aid package?? Possibly provided ignoramuses like Kerry have their way in the US Congress, but this time Congress is very concerned because they are now aware of double game played by Pak and more importantly the Israeli lobby is very much concerned about Taleban and Pak as evidenced by what its FM Avigdor Liebermann). OK back to the topic. If there is a military coup and Pak Army gets really pushed around by Unkil to fight the Taleban, things will get very interesting. Then there could be a possible split between officer class who love their whiskey, $$$, US (because most of their sons and daughters are in the US) and housing and land benefits, and the poor jawans who associate much more closely with the Quran, mullahs and possibly some Pakhtuns.

    Do not forget a message from the telephone conversation that RAW intercepted during Kargil War between Brigadier and Mian Musharraf where Brig says

    “The jehadis are fully under our control. I repeat, the jehadis are fully under our control”.

    Not sure how long the jernails can say this the way things are unfolding in Pak. Not sure what the endgame is either. Interesting times indeed.

  87. Baitullah Kurramzai
    May 4th, 2009 @ 8:33 am

    Allah Kasam, Tu harami haram ka baccha marega talib ke goli se. Jinda dafnayenge thuje.

  88. Arwinder Singh
    May 4th, 2009 @ 8:52 am

    For Jaswant Thakre :

    Hello Jaswant Thakre, What we are facing is a internal contradiction of liberalism. Experiment started by Raja Ram Mohan Roy has entered into serious crisis. If India played into hands of foriegn hostile powers it will go to war with tremendous loss of human life. A bomb will not ask you if you are a muslim or hindu before exploding above your head. War is South Asia goes against interests of India.

    India do not need Raja Ram Mohan Roy. Neither it need right wing fascism to solve this. What it needs is vedic knowledge of Aryans of Antiquity before they came to India or even central Asia. Before vedic knowledge was polluted with Indo-Babel-sumerian beliefs and myths.

    Should We Blame Muslims? Pollution of vedic knowledge is not something we can blame muslims for? Prophet Muhammed’s revolution was against same corruption in Arabia. This is same corruption which polluted Vedas. This is same corruption which serves as foundation principles for modern Liberalism.

  89. Arwinder Singh
    May 4th, 2009 @ 9:22 am

    For Our Muslim Friends:

    Some of muslims on this forum think Prophet Muhammed(pbuh) as their personal property. Any body be they muslim or non-muslm can take his name and read his words and they dont need your permission to do so. A donkey who has love of Allah in his heart will be wiser then you so venom spitting so-called muslim idiots.

    A muslim who do not have love of Ali in his heart is Kafir. But what you will call a kafir who has love of Ali in his heart? Quote (Indian historian asked Pakitani intellectuals in a forum in pakistan) 

  90. Sandeep
    May 6th, 2009 @ 6:33 am

    Namaste Maloy Ji.

    I’d like to thank on behalf of all ‘infidels’ ..i.e. all humans. I hope God (not Allah- the ficticious character created by Mohammad for self interest)  saves poor Pakistan from hands of Taliban.

    Please keep writing. 
    Dhanyawad.

  91. Les derniers jours du Pakistan ? (1) - les carnets de clarisse
    July 1st, 2009 @ 3:35 am

    [...] Maloy Krishna Dhar, 14 avril : une analyse très complète et fouillée, comme toujours, sur le blog de l’ancien [...]

  92. Yong Phoenix
    December 24th, 2009 @ 4:42 pm

    Just imagine I read it twice. While I am not as proficient on this issue, I match with your closings because they create sense. Thanks and goodluck to you.

  93. Madelaine Berlo
    December 26th, 2009 @ 5:04 pm

    This is my first time i visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work.

  94. personal injury lawyers canberra
    January 10th, 2011 @ 3:35 pm

    Hey – nice blog, just looking around some blogs, appears a pretty good platform you might be making use of. I’m currently utilizing WordPress for a few of my sites but looking to change one of them over to a platform comparable to yours like a trial run. Something in particular you would recommend about it?

Leave a Reply





  • Buy Books

    Shakti

    Shakti

    Shakti

    train To India

    People of India

    Black Thunder

    Fulcrum of Evil

    Open Secrets

    Operation Triple X

    Mission Pakistan

    Vernacular

    Gangland Democracy

    Kauri Fasal

    Kidwai Fasal

    Khule Rahasiya

    Khule Bhed